The Feminine Mystique

Perhaps the single most useful tool women have possessed for centuries is their unknowablity. I made that word up, but it’s applicable; women of all generations for hundreds of years have cultivated this sense of being unknowable, random or in worse case fickle or ambiguous. This is the feminine mystique and it goes hand in hand with the feminine prerogative – a woman always reserves the right to change her mind – and the (mythical) feminine intuition – “a woman just knows.” While a Man can never be respected for anything less than being forthright and resolute – say what you mean, mean what you say – women are rewarded and reinforced by society for being elusive and, dare I say, seemingly irrational. In fact, if done with the right art, it’s exactly this elusiveness that makes her both desirable and intolerably frustrating. However, to pull this off she must be (or seem to be) unknowable, and encourage all of male society to believe so.

The feminine mystique appeals to the feminine psyche for the same reasons ‘chick crack’ works so well in PUA technique. It appeals to the same ‘secret power’ dynamic that makes meta-physical associations so attractive (religion, superstition, intuition, etc.) One need look no further than women’s innate love of gossip to understand; There’s power in secrets for women. It’s hardly a surprise that connections with witchcraft have been associated with the feminine for so long. In an historically male dominated culture it follows that the power of secrecy and mysticism would need to be cultivated into the feminine as a resource for influencing the men in control of it. Sometimes that may have ended with a woman burned at the stake, but more often it was a means to becoming the ‘power behind the throne’ by degrees, and depending upon the status of the man she could enchant.

Combine that mysticism with sexuality, and you’ve got the feminine mystique – the most useful tool the feminine imperative possesses in it’s quest for optimal hypergamy.

The feminine mystique permeates inter-gender communication. On every forum response, on every blog comment, on every facebook post and in any article ever written by women with a personal, feminine investment in the subject, there is a residue of recognizing the feminine mystique. When a woman retorts to an observation of  female behavior that betrays female intent, the standard misdirection is ALWAYS saturated in the unknowable, unpredictably capricious, feminine mystique. The first (and second) rule of Fight Club for the feminine imperative is to protect the mystery of the female – and the sisterhood has no mercy for those who would betray that. To quote Roissy, the closer you get to truth the louder women screech.

For years I’ve striven to breakdown confusion and common problems by observing behavior. Women are human beings with the same basic motivations that men are subject to with some greater or lesser variation in their reasoning and methodologies. The point being is that women are every bit as subject to being as mundane or as extraordinary as men are, but the difference is that men don’t enjoy a masculine mystique. With rare exceptions, we don’t generally cultivate this sense of mystery because we’re not rewarded for it to the degree women are – and honestly, we haven’t needed to. But for a woman, if she can cultivate this mystique, her attentions become a reward unto themselves for the guy who is ‘lucky’ enough to tame her. Rest assured, when you think a woman is crazy, she’s crazy like a fox; she’s crazy with a reason. Women are every bit as calculating as men, in fact more so I’d argue because they have the mystique to hide a multitude of sins behind. They’re not irrational, they’re calculated – you just have to develop an ability to read a woman’s actions and behaviors and see the latent purpose behind them.

In contemporary times, men are far too ready to write off women as irrational agents. Even Freud was fooled by the hysterics of women’s responses and wrote them off as largely incapable, random and duplicitous to their own interests. I can’t begin to tell you how frustrating it is to hear an elderly man say “women, I guess we’ll never really understand them, huh?” How many times have you been asked by a friend, “so, did ya get lucky with Kristy last night?” We don’t think much of this passing question, but it’s framed in such a way that men autonomously perpetuate the myth of this mystique. It’s not luck that gets you laid. I understand that circumstance and being the right guy at the right time most certainly plays a part, but that’s not the operative here. However, if we feel as though we got lucky, we won the lottery, or walked away with a rare and valuable PRIZE, it doesn’t help us to understand what it is we did correctly in a given instance. Not only that, it perpetuates women as the mysterious prize-givers and ensures they maintain an indirectly primary power role in embodying the prize that is feared to be lost. You were lucky to have gotten sex with this mysterious woman so it must be something rare and valuable indeed.

The feminine mystique discourages questioning the process or the motives involved in inter-gender relations; men are just happy to have had the chance of experiencing the unkowable woman they scarcely understand. When mixed with sexual deprivation, the lucky fate element makes the sex that much more absorbing. It’s this luck precognition for men and fostered by women that leads to the scarcity mentality and often (but not exclusively) ONEitis in men. It serve the feminine if men willingly adopt the feminine mystique mindset with regards to their intimacy. Sexuality is a woman’s first, best agency and any social mechanism that contributes to the value of it will always be encouraged.

Published by Rollo Tomassi

Author of The Rational Male and The Rational Male, Preventive Medicine

Leave a Reply

  Subscribe  
Notify of
unbowed
Guest
unbowed
Offline

A woman I was seeing for 7 months essentially broke up with me without actually telling me she was breaking up with me. A month ago, we had a celebration (she treated me) and I reacted by revealing I was happy with her–not very mysterious of me and I was punished for this. She called me a few days later and said she just couldn’t date for a while, she had to go away for a bit, was simply too busy. Since then, nothing but scarce texts. Posts like this one and the previous one (women’s behavior, not their words… Read more »

Will S.
Guest
Will S.
Offline

Spot on. Back before my ‘red pill’ days, I used to laugh along and shake my head along with, and tell, those “who can understand women?” jokes. Now that I do understand women, I’ve been waiting for an opportunity to tell the next guy who says one of those that I don’t see the humour any more, and there’s a good reason why…

Rollo Tomassi
Guest
Rollo Tomassi
Offline

An integral part of the feminine ‘shaming’ dynamic is to presume that a man even suggesting he “understands women” should be ridiculed back into a state of unquestioning compliance with the female imperative. Just the attempt for a man to understand the feminine is laughable.

Not only this, but the need for protecting the veil of mystery is so strong that male identifiers had to be recruited and socially rewarded for joining in the shaming. This is why it’s ‘funny’ to joke with other guys about how men will never understand women.

MacAgent
Guest
MacAgent
Offline

“They’re not irrational, they’re calculated…” Dead on truth! Amen brother.

Y
Guest
Y
Offline

@Will S.

1st rule of Fight Club is don’t talk about Fight Club.

Next time you hear someone tell a joke like that just smile and shrug.

If there’s a woman around, give her a knowing look.

You’re part of the inner circle now.

carolyn
Guest
carolyn
Offline

i think it goes both ways. men are mysterious to me. they are so different. not that i’m not occasionally baffled by the behavior of some women, but men are so alien. what on earth makes them tick? i never discussed this with other women and so don’t know their take. maybe i’m an outlier, i dunno. this may be tmi from this long married woman-during orgasm with my husband, i think (to the extent one can think) ‘_now_ i really get it,finally i understand’ but it’s only momentary. soon that epiphany slips out of my grasp. i can’t hold… Read more »

Neecy
Guest
Neecy
Offline

Women have *never* been a mystery. That is an ideal created by MALES. Men have been the ones who have buried their heads in the sand about who and what women truly are. For decades males created these images and rules on what women were to be. Women had no power for long periods of time and thus upheld this image that MEN wanted women to be – not who we really were. Fast forward to Feminism, and now men are really seeing who women are. Actually, if there was one good thing about Feminism, it was the fact the… Read more »

Deep Dish
Guest
Deep Dish
Offline

To quote from the preface of the 48 Laws of Power, “Those who claim to be nonplayers may affect an air of naïveté, to protect them from the accusation that they are after power. Beware, again, however, for the appearance of naïveté can be an effective means of deceit (see Law 21, Seem Dumber Than Your Mark). And even genuine naïveté is not free from the snares of power… Genuinely innocent people may still be playing for power, and are often horribly effective at the game, since they are not hindered by reflection. Once again, those who make a show… Read more »

Good Luck Chuck
Guest
Good Luck Chuck
Offline

Dish- that quote describes the nature of women at their core. There are quite a few things that women are oblivious to or only peripherally aware of that they use to mercilessly play the mating game to their advantage. Take “feminine virtue” for example, which is yet another concept that is perpetuated by women and their white knight minions. Ask a few random people which sex is morally superior. Of course those of us here realize that the idea of women being morally superior to men is laughable but I am willing to bet that most all women and the… Read more »

johnnymilfquest
Guest

Yes, Patriarchy is gone now. Good luck finding a husband.

Rollo Tomassi
Guest
Rollo Tomassi
Offline

Why is it considered rude to directly inquire about a woman’s age and not a man’s? Why do women take offense to questions about their weight, yet men are more or less indifferent about it? Why would it be socially inadvisable for me to ask an unfamiliar woman if she’s presently having her period? For centuries, we’ve been acculturated into the feminine social convention that there are a variety of gender specific questions that are considered rude to ask of a woman, but are unimportant to men; why has knowledge of this specific information been deemed proprietary to women? Because… Read more »

Deep Dish
Guest
Deep Dish
Offline

I think I screwed up the WordPress comments. Everything after my post was italics, because I made a typo in ending the HTML tag. I’m hoping this comment fixes it.

Deep Dish
Guest
Deep Dish
Offline

I guess not.

Rollo Tomassi
Guest
Rollo Tomassi
Offline

Fixed.

Neecy
Guest
Neecy
Offline

Rollo, Of course women also adapted to the ideal of the Mystique so of course they created ways to uphold it by the various things you listed. But Women never set out to hide who they really were on their own or initially. It was feminism that allowed women to finally be who they really were. Women didn’t have much power during certain eras and didn’t even have any choice to be anything other than what men needed and wanted them to be. In fact I think most women today are relieved to be able to be who they want… Read more »

Good Luck Chuck
Guest
Good Luck Chuck
Offline

“Women didn’t have much power during certain eras and didn’t even have any choice to be anything other than what men needed and wanted them to be.” During certain eras life was hard and neither men nor women had the LUXURY of being “who they wanted to be”. This idea that these poor women were forced into a life of unhappiness and servitude back in the day is laughable to anyone with enough of a brain to realize that things were a little different 100 years ago. You have been around these blogs long enough I would have hoped you… Read more »

Neecy
Guest
Neecy
Offline

For the sake of the topic I was pointing out that the only reason women were ever deemed mysterious etc. Was b/c men wanted and encouraged this behavior from women during times when women had little power. Now that women have some power to be who they want, the blindfold has been removed on the “mystique” of women. Either that or women and men are just different today than they were yesterday.

Deep Dish
Guest
Deep Dish
Offline

If it were true there is no preservation of the mystique, why is it that almost any time any man criticizes, speaks out again, writes a treatise analyzing the grotesque nature of women, he’s essentially more or less questioned as a bitter misogynistic loser? Women always screech, in various degrees of sophistication. If there’s no mystique, why?

Deep Dish
Guest
Deep Dish
Offline

More pointedly, why is this quote true: “Men are not troubled to hear a man dispraised, because they know, though he be naught, there’s worth in others; but women are mightily troubled to hear any of them spoken against, as if the sex itself were guilty of some unworthiness.”

Deep Dish
Guest
Deep Dish
Offline

*against

Neecy
Guest
Neecy
Offline

Well Deep Dish I just think women have adapted to being seen as being a mystery and a gender that should be forgiven for certain transgressions. I don’t think women adapt this frame of thought as to be sinister, its just we don’t know anything different. We were born into this way of being seen as women and adjusted as such. I think women do like to believe we are a mystery. i honestly believed it up until I started reading game blogs and realizing women were doing things against the natural “feminine” ways. I’m a woman of many who… Read more »

Good Luck Chuck
Guest
Good Luck Chuck
Offline

Males of this generation seek the truth out of necessity. Game and the study of evo psychology are adaptations to the pressures of a mating market that is skewed in favor of women.

108spirits
Guest
108spirits
Offline

Why do my eyes hurt? It’s because I’m getting deja vu from reading a Tomassi’s post again! grin j/k mate, about time you have a blog (JB from SS).

This feminine mystique (I keep thinking of Rebecca Romjin’s incredible body as I read this blog) might’ve been a female construct at first, but I’m sure men went along at first because that was the only way a man could truly love a woman. If he understood her true nature, how could he love her?

trackback

[…] the value can be increased, thus ensuring a controlling frame. This convention holds fast to the Feminine Mystique or Female Intuition mythology. So long as women remain ‘uknowable’ there becomes less […]

Emma the Emo
Guest

“Why would it be socially inadvisable for me to ask an unfamiliar woman if she’s presently having her period?”

I can agree with you on those other questions, but this one is like asking an unfamiliar man about the size of his penis. Kind of a weird question to ask a stranger.

Sam
Guest
Sam
Offline

Since a woman acts and responds differently when she is having her period, it is actually a practically relevant piece of information.

trackback
Sexy «
Offline

[…] of what I can only presume is men’s inability to fully comprehend sexiness, beauty and the feminine mystique. Fat acceptance and body image issues aside, it’s ironic that the same women nodding along in […]

trackback

[…] motivator makes for an ideal environment in which to practice hypergamy. The unknowability of the feminine mystique, a woman’s prerogative to change her mind and the default status of victimhood, all find […]

trackback

[…] characterizations. In keeping with the very useful associations of women’s unknowability and feminine mystique, it’s perhaps unsurprising that we find most mythologized representations of women and […]

trackback

[…] sexual market value or potential value. Additionally, the shaming man protects the utility of the feminine mystique by perpetuating the myth that women are intrinsically unknowable creatures. “You’ll […]

trackback

[…] The Feminine Mystique […]

trackback

[…] I detailed in the Feminine Mystique, from a social perspective, the feminine imperative can’t afford men understanding the […]

trackback

[…] Feminine mystique – http://rationalmale.wordpress.com/2011/09/07/the-feminine-mystique/ […]

trackback

[…] Years ago, when I was writing this post, my emphasis was on how an evolved dynamic (female pluralistic sexual strategy) translated into evolved social dynamics (feminine primary social conventions). My focus then was on how the feminine creates and normalizes social conditions that favor hypergamy by covertly manipulating social expectations – not only of the men who would facilitate that hypergamy, but also for women themselves in how their own self-rationalizations (hindbrain, hamsters) can be socially justified (i.e the myth of  the feminine mystique). […]

trackback

[…] on to avoid this. The feminine prerogative (she can change her mind) being the most useful, or The Feminine Mystique (women are unknowable) being a close second […]

trackback

[…] [The Feminine Mystique] […]

trackback

[…] women were,  but why women were. Game was making the unknowable woman knowable. The enigmatic feminine mystique began unraveling with each new contribution to the Game knowledge […]

trackback

[…] to reach critical cultural mass and get the patina started in the first place. Feminists likewise rely on a mystique of superior fairness and moral purity. Can’t you feel […]

trackback

[…] a woman can uniquely supply – unknowable, fantastical love. It’s part and parcel of the Myth of the Feminine Mystique which makes women the gatekeepers of the knowledge of love; don’t try to understand it with […]

trackback

[…] for women. In the same vein as a Woman’s Prerogative (women can change their minds) and the Feminine Mystique, female histrionics are a legitimized and socially excusable tactic with the latent purpose of […]

trackback
Empathy |
Offline

[…] traced back to the Mother-Nurturer myth attributed to the feminine as well as the mysticism of the Feminine Mystique. If women are the unquestionably unknowable forces of nature that the Mystique constantly batters […]

trackback

[…] this weak, twistable structure of opinions (beta male reality) reinforces the prevalence of “The Feminine Mystique” and in terms of professional success it reinforces the notion that wealth is mostly achieved by […]

trackback

[…] Artículo de Rollo Tomassi, The Rational Male […]

trackback

[…] when you really take a look there are  hundreds of blogs like these DEDICATED to cracking the “feminine mystique”  . The results have helped a lot more men, women, and relationships than a Disney movie could ever […]

trackback

[…] create models that would explain all kinds of erratic female behaviour. We don’t buy into the Feminine Mystique. Well, the funny thing is that I was unable to find a good explanation for the concept of the point […]

Driver
Guest
Driver
Offline

It’s interesting to read responses from women on this one. Women “back when” were the ones competing for the best man (i.e. most land, wealth, assets, etc…) with all other women so it was best that each woman created this “mystery”…to stand out from other women. We see it, today, on social media with selfies, tats, hair coloring, etc….to stand out (grab attention). Women can argue all day long that a man created this “mystique” but in my opinion it’s nonsense. It’s women competing for survival (or the best) so they are using all tools necessary in their tool kit.… Read more »

trackback

[…] Feminine mystique, the magic that delighted men of past-generations, has been systematically exploited to the point where learning the truth behind it has tilted the cost-benefit balance beam of trust toward benefit. While it takes the romanticism out men’s interactions with women, their lives greatly benefit from understanding how the game works. […]

trackback

[…] Feminine mystique, the magic that delighted men of past-generations, has been systematically exploited to the point where learning the truth behind it has tilted the cost-benefit balance beam of trust toward benefit. While it takes the romanticism out men’s interactions with women, their lives greatly benefit from understanding how the game works. […]

trackback

[…] Feminine mystique, the magic that delighted men of past-generations, has been systematically exploited to the point where learning the truth behind it has tilted the cost-benefit balance beam of trust toward benefit. While it takes the romanticism out men’s interactions with women, their lives greatly benefit from understanding how the game works. […]

trackback

[…] Once you accept this, she’s earned a lifetime of get-out-of-jail-free cards. The myth of the ‘Feminine Mystique’ and a woman’s prerogative (to change her mind) is entirely dependent upon this covert […]

Colinizor
Guest
Colinizor
Offline

The comments by the women above sound to me that they have no clue what men are settimg out to achieve here. Confirms to me Rollo is accurate in his observations. Oh well, at lest they are here I suppose. In regards to men encourging mystique in a woman as a man I say its bullshit. A man wants as easiest possibleway to fuck a woman when and how it suits him. Trouble is they have been hoodwimked into jumping hoops put up by women. I personally jump through no hoops for no women and get as much sex as… Read more »

Omega Man
Guest
Omega Man
Offline

“you either love women or you understand women, but you can’t do both.” to that i add, “or you learn to read thru their bullshit tactics & schemes.” watch their behavior. i have 3 sisters, and i watched them play the games, tell the lies, and be exactly opposite to the “sugar & spice & everything nice” bullshit. further, i’ve seen them use horoscopes, memes, and other social media quotes to seem mysterious and intuitive… like some weird fortune teller. all of this was used to fool various guys into thinking they were something they were not. the make-up, all… Read more »

trackback

[…] In The Feminine Mystique I outlined the latent purpose the Feminine Imperative foments in the mythology of women being these fickle, unpredictable and unknowable enigmas to men. […]

trackback

[…] some naturally occurring biological or psychological event that can be conveniently attached to the mystique of […]

Tom
Guest
Tom
Offline

Omega

Quote all too true as us redpillers know.

I’m not sure quite enough is made of the sisters dynamic. Many naturals or just men who did ok with women from an early age cite their sisters/sisters friends as a part of their early unplugging. And that’s just the ones who use these sites with the prerequisite self-awareness to make the connection.

Conversely many pedestalising betas with romantically idealised ideas about the “fairer” sex i would bet were only children or only had brothers (yours truly).

trackback

[…] fallout and shame. Whereas men’s instincts are signs of ‘insecurity’, women’s instincts (feminine intuition) are raised to a metaphysical level. So when a woman says a guy “creeps her out” or is acting […]

trackback

[…] nothing is more flattering for a woman to believe that she’s figured out a man by using her mythological feminine intuition. However, there is a flip side to this ego-compliment to women, and that’s when her […]

trackback

[…] Çeviri : Feminine Mystique […]

Tollo Romasi
Guest
Tollo Romasi
Offline

You think you made up the word ‘unknowability’? It’s a fairly common word.

trackback

[…] talked about the frustration of the attraction phenomena, among many other things related to the feminine mystique – both complicated subjects which were only exposed about a decade later, and which are now […]

trackback

[…] Kaynak: The feminine mystique […]

anythinggoes75
Guest
anythinggoes75
Offline

Great post as always. Since I’m reading these posts carefully anyway, I just wanted to point out the minor possible typos just in case you ever wanted to go back and fix them. No disrespect intended at all. This sentence sounded like it should say serves instead of “serve”.

“It serve the feminine if men willingly adopt the feminine mystique mindset with regards to their intimacy.”

Chris
Guest
Chris
Offline

This is so true, men are always asked “did you get lucky”…women are never asked “did you get lucky”. For women they’re asked “Did you sleep with him?”, like every guy is interchangeable, and it was purely their decision because they are always on the pedestal. Great website. I just stumbled on it today.

%d bloggers like this: